Whisky Connosr
Menu
Shop

Kilkerran 12 Year Old

Well Worth The Wait

2 1290

@MaltActivistReview by @MaltActivist

28th Aug 2016

0

Kilkerran 12 Year Old
  • Nose
    ~
  • Taste
    ~
  • Finish
    ~
  • Balance
    ~
  • Overall
    90

Show rating data charts

Distribution of ratings for this: brand user

About five years ago at my clubs' monthly mystery tasting I decided to take with me a relatively unknown whisky. Well, unknown to most of us, that is.

It was something I picked up on a whim without really knowing anything about it or the distillery. That whisky was the Kilkerran WIP 4. Met with many a raised eyebrow and unabashed lip smacking it became an instant hit at the gathering and ultimately my obsession.

For those who know me know two things about me.

Number 1 : I have a mild case of OCD. Which means if you give me something that is numbered and part of a series then I will move mountains to make sure I have the entire collection. It's a sickness, I admit it.

Number 2 : I am irrationally fascinated by Campbeltown whiskies. No rhyme or reason. Just am.

Now imagine my state when you put both those things together. Even more so when the spirit in question is just so damned delicious. And, thus, began my quest to collect all the WIPs.

Glengyle Distillery, makers of Kilkerran, released the WIP 1, which was a five year old whisky, as a way of sharing the spirits' journey until it's final form as a 12 year old. Also no doubt as a crafty means of generating revenue which is fine by me. This was, you guessed it, followed by the WIP 2 and so on until last year they released their last and final WIP (the 7) which was a stunning bourbon cask bottled at cask strength.

And, finally, around two weeks ago they released their standard entry level - the 12 year old. I have been following this journey for a while now and was understandably excited when they announced the release. After making my pre-order I somehow managed to have it with me for a tasting I hosted a couple of nights ago.

Geeks that we are we didn't try it straight and instead decided to do a vertical with the WIP 5,6 & 7 followed by the 12.

My sample is from a brand new bottle and served at 46%

Immediate grill charcoal. Faint coal smoke. Almost industrial diesel. Not in an overpowering way but in a way that only Campbeltown can make appealing. Himalayan pink salt. Green olives in brine. Mexican lime. Vanilla. Very mild honey. Wild heather. Dry flowers. Love the nose. There's an old-school oiliness to this that I love.

Touch bitter. But in a good way. Vanilla. Sweet lemon. Touch of oak. Consistent layer of smoke. Wet pebbles. That salt again. Get's sweeter mid-palate. Butterscotch. And then black pepper pricks. Solid.

Medium to long. Oak. Lindt 90% cocoa. Ceylon black tea.

I love it. I love the WIP 7 a bit more but this one is quite lovely. I love it because there is an element of old-fashioned whisky making that somehow comes through it's oiliness and the fact that it's more savoury than sweet. Something which I really like in a whisky. This might not be everyone's cup of tea but it certainly is mine. What I appreciate even more is the highly affordable price tag. Under 40GBP in a world that has gone crazy is something to be lauded. So thank you Glengyle for not being greedy gits. And for producing this gem.

8.4

Related Kilkerran reviews

12 comments

@Alexsweden
Alexsweden commented

Sounds like they delivered the goods after all of the great WIPs. I'll be sure to try this one when I get a chance

7 years ago 0

@MaltActivist
MaltActivist commented

@Alexsweden they sure did. One of the better entry level whiskies today at an unbeatable price.

7 years ago 0

@Robert99
Robert99 commented

@MaltActivist Is your score 90 or 84? In any case, it is a very nice review. This one checks a lot of boxes for me: diesel, grill charcoal and coal, pebbles, pepper, cocoa and tea. Sounds like a winner to me! Now, I need to find a way to get one.

7 years ago 0

@MaltActivist
MaltActivist commented

@Robert99 my connosr score is 90

8.4 is the score on my blog which roughly translates to 90 on the connosr scale.

Hope you find yourself a bottle soon! But I'd be on the lookout for the WIP7 CS if I were you.

7 years ago 0

@Alexsweden
Alexsweden commented

I found the WIP7 Sherry cask very nice as well.

7 years ago 0

@Robert99
Robert99 commented

@MaltActivist Thank you for the answer and the advise. I was able to spot the Kilkerran 12 and the WIP6 (Bourbon finish) near somebody I know but now I have to get in contact with that person and convince her to grab it for me. I hesitate because that person (my niece) has recently been very helpful in getting very good stuff and I don't want to alienate this fine ressource. I also have to admit, I am currently short on my whisky money. I read very good review of the WIP6, where would you rank it compare to the WIP7 and the 12 yo?

7 years ago 0

@MaltActivist
MaltActivist commented

@Robert99 I like the WIP7 the most. The WIP6 Sherry a little more than the WIP6 Bourbon.

And the 12, for me, sits between the WIP6 Bourbon and Sherry - if you're to believe the scores that is. And maybe that's a fair representation considering that the 12 is 30% sherry and the rest bourbon.

7 years ago 0

maltmate302 commented

I also rate the WIP 7 CS as the best Kilkerran so far but the 12 is close to it, very close indeed.Every Kilkerran I've had so far has been superb and i'm happy that I have gallons of the stuff put away!

7 years ago 0

@Ol_Jas
Ol_Jas commented

MaltActivist, how prominent would you say the salt is on this one? I'm gonna buy one regardless when it appears around me, but I'm wondering how much of that big Campbeltown salt hit I can expect.

When I first tasted a Campbeltown whisky (a vatted mystery malt that's probably nearly all Springbank, from behind the counter at the Edinburgh Cadenhead's), I was blown away by the sea-saltiness. I loved it. When I subsequently first drank a Springbank 10 back home, the salt was still there and I loved it again. Since then, I've been chasing that character and finding it less and less. The reason is probably my acclimation to heavily peated whisky (rather any broad changes in whisky), but nonetheless, I keep looking for something that will make me feel young again, as it were. I've found it to varying degrees in the Kilkerrans I've had so far, but nothing huge. Serge's review of the new 12 really emphasizes the saltiness, so I got my fingers crossed for this one.

7 years ago 0

@MaltActivist
MaltActivist commented

@OlJas I guess enough salt for me to compare it to Himalayan sea-salt as well as green olive brine.

7 years ago 0

@Ol_Jas
Ol_Jas commented

@MaltActivist , yes, those are good salty omens! Thanks.

How did you ever do with completing your WIP collection?

7 years ago 0